The Ocean Front: India’s Role in the Indian Ocean Region (IOR) – Challenges and Strategic Outlook

Introduction

  • India’s geopolitical and strategic interests in the Indian Ocean Region (IOR) are increasing due to rising global power competition.
  • Despite efforts, institutional voids, security threats, and external influences hinder India’s ability to act as the leading power in the region.

Challenges in the Indian Ocean Region (IOR)

1. Institutional Fragmentation and Lack of Coordination

  • Unlike other regions, the IOR lacks a strong collective security mechanism like NATO or ASEAN.
  • Regional organizations such as IORA (Indian Ocean Rim Association) and IONS (Indian Ocean Naval Symposium) remain largely symbolic rather than operationally effective.
  • Absence of binding agreements results in limited cooperation on security, trade, and maritime governance.

2. Increasing Chinese Influence in the IOR

  • China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and String of Pearls strategy are strengthening its foothold in the region.
  • Chinese military and economic presence in Djibouti, Sri Lanka, Pakistan (Gwadar), and the Maldives threatens India’s traditional dominance.
  • The dual-use ports developed by China pose a security challenge for India’s naval operations.

3. Maritime Security and Piracy Threats

  • The region faces persistent threats from piracy (off the coast of Somalia), illegal fishing, drug trafficking, and smuggling.
  • Terrorist infiltration through maritime routes, as seen in the 26/11 Mumbai attacks, remains a concern.
  • Non-traditional security threats such as cyber threats to maritime infrastructure and climate change-induced displacement add to the complexity.

4. Absence of a Clear Strategic Doctrine

  • While India has SAGAR (Security and Growth for All in the Region) as a vision, a comprehensive maritime security doctrine is lacking.
  • The Indian Navy’s presence is substantial, but coordination with other security agencies like the Indian Coast Guard and regional navies needs strengthening.
  • Lack of a long-term funding commitment for regional security programs hinders India’s strategic outreach.

5. External Powers and the Indo-Pacific Debate

  • The rise of the Indo-Pacific concept, led by the US, Japan, and Australia (QUAD), has diverted focus from IOR-specific issues.
  • France and the UK are also increasing their naval presence, creating overlapping interests and reducing India’s strategic autonomy.
  • India’s reluctance to take an aggressive stance in balancing US and Chinese influence weakens its leadership claims.

6. Delays in Maritime Infrastructure Development

  • India’s port development and connectivity projects in the region (e.g., Chabahar in Iran, Agalega in Mauritius) face bureaucratic and diplomatic delays.
  • MEA and MoD coordination gaps slow down projects like HADR (Humanitarian Assistance and Disaster Relief) initiatives and defense agreements.
  • Countries in the region still prefer Chinese investments due to quicker execution and financial backing.

Way Forward for this situation

1. Strengthening Institutional Mechanisms

  • Lead the Reform of IORA & IONS: India should push for a more structured and binding framework within the Indian Ocean Rim Association (IORA) and Indian Ocean Naval Symposium (IONS).
  • Enhancing Regional Cooperation: Encourage formal security and trade agreements to bring together smaller nations of the IOR under a common strategic vision.
  • Maritime Security Treaty: Establish a regional security charter to counter common threats such as piracy, illegal fishing, and terrorism.

2. Countering Chinese Influence through Strategic Partnerships

  • Expanding Naval and Defense Collaborations: Strengthen security ties with Mauritius, Seychelles, Sri Lanka, Maldives, Indonesia, and East African nations.
  • Bilateral and Multilateral Defense Agreements: Use QUAD, BIMSTEC, and ASEAN frameworks to counterbalance China’s influence in the region.
  • Accelerate the SAGAR Vision: India’s “Security and Growth for All in the Region” (SAGAR) must be institutionalized, ensuring a consistent diplomatic and security presence.

3. Strengthening Maritime Capabilities and Infrastructure

  • Expanding Naval Presence: Establish permanent naval outposts in key locations like Mauritius (Agalega), Madagascar, and Seychelles to monitor maritime traffic and security threats.
  • Rapid Expansion of Maritime Domain Awareness (MDA): Invest in underwater surveillance, satellite-based monitoring, and AI-driven maritime intelligence systems.
  • Upgrading Port Infrastructure: Expedite Chabahar Port development in Iran and enhance connectivity to Africa and the Middle East.

4. Enhancing Humanitarian and Disaster Response (HADR) Capabilities

  • Fast-Track Disaster Relief Operations: Strengthen India’s role as a first responder in natural disasters and conflicts in the IOR region.
  • Develop an Integrated Maritime HADR Framework: Coordinate efforts between the Indian Navy, Coast Guard, and Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) to respond swiftly to regional crises.
  • Promote Soft Power Diplomacy: Establish medical missions, maritime training programs, and cultural exchanges to deepen goodwill.

5. Economic and Trade Engagement in the IOR

  • Promoting “Blue Economy” Diplomacy: Facilitate trade agreements and joint ventures in marine fisheries, renewable energy, and deep-sea mining.
  • Strengthening Indian Industry Investments: Encourage Indian businesses to invest in infrastructure, energy, and technology sectors in IOR nations.
  • Establishing an Indian Ocean Economic Corridor: Develop a network of trade and energy partnerships linking South Asia, Africa, and Southeast Asia.

6. Synchronizing Diplomatic and Defense Efforts

  • Strengthen Coordination Between MEA and MoD: Eliminate bureaucratic inefficiencies that delay strategic projects in IOR.
  • Craft an “Indian Ocean Security Doctrine”: Develop a comprehensive naval and foreign policy roadmap to safeguard India’s interests.
  • Leverage QUAD & Indo-Pacific Synergy: Align India’s regional strategy with the broader Indo-Pacific framework while maintaining autonomy in the IOR.

India’s Strategic Response

  • Strengthening IORA and IONS by taking a leadership role in decision-making and policy formulation.
  • Expanding maritime diplomacy through joint naval exercises, strategic port development, and defense partnerships with smaller IOR states.
  • Enhancing maritime domain awareness (MDA) to counter China’s growing presence and intelligence-gathering activities.
  • Improving disaster relief and humanitarian assistance (HADR) mechanisms to project India as a first responder.
  • Developing a long-term Indian Ocean security strategy that integrates military, diplomatic, and economic efforts.

Conclusion

  • The Indian Ocean is central to India’s security and economic interests, but institutional weaknesses, external pressures, and maritime threats hinder its strategic objectives.
  • India must assert its leadership by enhancing naval capabilities, securing regional partnerships, and proactively shaping the security architecture.
  • A well-defined Indian Ocean Strategy, backed by investment, diplomacy, and strategic military presence, will be key in countering Chinese influence and reinforcing India’s role as the dominant power in the region.

Also Read Astronauts to Return: Causes of Delay and Lessons Learned

Tags: , ,